I will never let someone control my frame again
Nathan Chadwick · · 12 min read
Listen
TLDRRead the short version
- The frame is whose version of the harm is allowed to be the harm. I have handed that over before. I will not hand it over again.
- When someone has wronged me and manipulated me, autism does not file it. I ruminate. The loop feels like understanding. It is the file staying open.
- Baseline is not a mood I can choose in the car park. Going over the harm keeps the stress response running long after the conversation has ended.
- The accountability I was trained to expect very rarely arrives. Accepting that is how I stop parking my nervous system on a confession that is not coming.
- In that room my feeling is secondary. A lot of the public talk about men's mental health does not survive contact with it.
- Social media pays both sexes to hate the other. Men and women still need each other. The person is specific. The hatred is general.
The frame#
Someone wrongs you. Then the conversation stops being about what they did.
It becomes your tone. Your message. Your face. The fact you are still talking about it. The fact you are autistic and "cannot let things go". By the end of the hour you are defending the reaction, and the original harm is a footnote you are no longer allowed to mention without proving you are the problem.
That is the frame. The frame is whose version of the event is allowed to be the event, and whose feeling is allowed to be the point.
I have lived inside someone else's frame. I have apologised for the injury while the injury was still mine. I have watched a manipulation get rewritten, in the same conversation, into a story where I was cruel for noticing it. I will not do that again. Not for peace. Not for a reunion. Not because the other story is louder in the room.
Keeping the frame is not refusing a correction. If I hurt you, the hurt stands. I wrote that about my own mouth in my senses are 10x, and I have no filter. A missing edit explains the speed. It does not delete the impact. The line I am drawing runs the other way. Your discomfort at being seen is not a veto on what you did. My nervous system taking a long time to settle is not evidence that the thing did not happen.
What the flip looks like#
Jennifer Freyd called the move DARVO: deny, attack, and reverse victim and offender. Deny the behaviour, or shrink it until it is nothing. Attack the person who named it, usually on credibility, stability, or motive. Then swap the roles, so the person who caused the harm is the one under attack, and the person who was harmed is the attacker for saying so.
Harsey and Freyd tested what that sequence does to an audience. People who watched it rated the victim as less believable and more responsible, and the perpetrator as less abusive. Those experiments were about interpersonal violence, not a tense Tuesday. The sequence is the same one a smaller harm uses when it needs a room. It worked on me from the inside, because I was already hunting for the version where I was the one who had failed. Give that hunt a script and it will run all night.
The tell is simple. After the conversation, say what the original harm was, in one sentence, without apologising for the sentence. If you cannot, the frame has already left.
I am taking it back. The harm is the harm. My reaction is a second fact, not a replacement for the first. Both can be true. Only one of them gets to erase the other, and I am done allowing it.
The file autism will not close#
I am autistic. When someone has wronged me, and the wrong came wrapped in a manipulation, I ruminate.
Not as a hobby, and not as a decision I am refusing to make. The event does not get filed. I go back over the message, the look, the sentence that moved the goalposts, the moment I started defending myself and forgot what I had walked in to say. I interview myself as the witness and the accused. I find a culprit, throw it out, and find another. I wrote about the mechanism in I need the why. An unexplained harm is an open file. Unsolved problems do not get archived. They get rehearsed.
Autism makes the rehearsal stick. The same mind that will not drop a noise will not drop a betrayal. Cooper and Russell compared autistic and non-autistic adults from the community and found the autistic group higher on rumination, with the repetitive thinking sitting between insistence on sameness and the anxiety and depression. Williams, McKenney and Gotham, in a network built from 608 autistic adults, found the rumination tied hardest to sadness and guilt, with the self-attacking thoughts in the middle of the web. That is my night. A structure, not a strategy. The guilt node is especially cruel when the guilt was installed by the person who did the thing. You ruminate on your own supposed failure, which is the frame they needed you to live in.
I know the loop is not insight. I wrote in feeling more is not emotional intelligence that rumination feels like depth and is often the emotion eating itself. Nolen-Hoeksema is blunt about what the loop does. It keeps the low mood going. It wrecks problem solving. It eats the support around you. Knowing the paper has not handed me an off switch. It has stopped me calling the loop wisdom.
How long the body takes#
People talk about getting back to baseline as if it were a decision you make before you get home.
The conversation ends. The body does not.
Brosschot, Gerin and Thayer argued that worry and rumination prolong the stress response after the stressor has gone, and sometimes before the next one arrives. They called it perseverative cognition. A later meta-analysis found that kind of thinking associated with higher heart rate and cortisol, and lower heart-rate variability. The argument can be finished in the room and unfinished in the cardiovascular system, because the mind is still presenting the argument as a current threat.
That is why I can look settled and be nowhere near it. Sleep goes thin. Sound comes up, which I already live at the wrong volume. A small comment the next day lands like the original blow, because the system never stood down. People read the delay as a grudge. A lot of it is recovery, dragged out by a brain that keeps reopening the file to check whether the harm was real.
I do not get to hurry this because someone is bored of it. I do not get to hurry it because I am bored of it either. The time is the time. What I can refuse is spending that time inside their frame, prosecuting myself for something they did, and calling the prosecution healing.
The accountability that does not come#
This is the part I resisted, because it sounded bitter, and I did not want the bitter version of myself to be the one who got the last word.
Women very rarely take accountability for the hurt they cause you.
I am not offering that as a census. I am offering it as the pattern I have actually met, and as the thing I have accepted so my nervous system can stop waiting at the door.
The account I needed was specific. The act, named, without the swap. What arrived instead was "I'm sorry you feel that way", which is a frame grab wearing a sorry. Or tears first, so my pain becomes the inconvenience and her pain becomes the event. Or a soft message three days later that skips the act and asks if we can move on, which means I will carry it and she will not have to look at it. I can count the real accounts on a short list. The rest were variations of the flip.
Men dodge too. I am not building a religion out of one sex's failure. I am saying that in the relationships where I was manipulated, the repair I had been trained to expect did not show up when it would have cost her the role of the injured party. The culture tells you she is better at this part. My body has the invoices.
Accepting that is not the same as hating her, or hating women. It is dropping a fantasy that was keeping me ill. If the account is not coming, the loop that exists to receive it has nothing honest to wait for. I can grieve the harm without leaving a chair out for a confession. That is the way it is. I would rather live there than in a hallway, rehearsing the sentence that would finally make her say it.
My feeling comes second#
Once the frame is hers, my feeling is secondary by definition. It is a reaction to be managed. It is "a lot". It is something we will get to after she feels safe, which is a queue that does not move, because her feeling is the emergency and mine is the evidence.
I have done the other job as well. Regulated myself, then regulated the room, then been told the regulation was coldness. I have written about that double load before. The point here is narrower. Even when I am plainly hurt, the hurt ranks below her discomfort at being the cause of it. A man's pain is allowed as a problem he has. It is much less often allowed as a problem she made.
So I have stopped offering the feeling up for a ranking. It is mine. It does not need to win a comparison with hers to be real. If a room can only hold one person's pain, and it is never mine, I am not staying in it to argue for a slot.
The slogan does not survive the room#
The posters are everywhere. Men's mental health matters. Talk to your mates. It is okay not to be okay.
The deaths are not the crap. In England and Wales in 2024 the suicide rate was 17.6 per 100,000 men and 5.7 per 100,000 women. Samaritans, on the England registrations, said three in four of those deaths were men. They also note that a relationship breakdown raises suicide risk more for men, and that men are less likely to say they are in trouble. Plenty of men who die have already touched a service and still not been held. If that is you, the number in the UK and Ireland is 116 123, and it does not require you to win the argument first.
What is a load of crap is the performance around those facts.
In the actual room, when a woman has hurt you, the slogan leaves. Your distress is dramatic, or controlling, or a failure to process, or proof you are unsafe to be around. Her distress is mental health. Yours is a character issue. The same culture that puts the poster up in a gym will side with the frame that makes you the problem for still being affected on Thursday. I have watched "men's mental health matters" fail the only test that counts. Does his pain still matter when it indicts her?
I am not waiting for the performance to promote my feeling out of second place. I have written before about depression being treated as a story someone had already finished, in the piece on SSRIs and testosterone. Same shape. Everyone had decided what sort of problem I was. A slogan is not the same as looking.
The feed is a separation machine#
Social media is bad for this in a specific way. It pays women to hate men, and it pays men to hate women.
Brady, Wills, Jost, Tucker and Van Bavel looked at hundreds of thousands of tweets about gun control, same-sex marriage, and climate change. Each extra moral-emotional word in a message was associated with about 20% more diffusion, and that extra spread stayed mostly inside the crowd that already agreed. The paper is about political issues, not about sex. The machine is the one I watch anyway. Moral feeling about the other side travels. A truce does not.
Point it at men and women and you get the timeline in front of me. Men as hazard, trash, project, disappointment. Women as shallow, disloyal, incapable of accounting for anything, the reason a life is hard. Each pile is built from real injuries, then inflated until a sex is the injury. The woman who manipulated me was a person. The feed would prefer her to be proof. The men who have been cruel, absent, or violent are people. The feed would prefer them to be proof the other way. Proof is how you stop having to meet anyone.
Both hatreds feel like clarity. They are drift. You rehearse contempt for the sex you still have to love, work beside, raise children with, be ill in front of, and grow old next to. You get fluent at a war you cannot win and cannot live in. The fluency is the product. It keeps you scrolling. It does not keep you company.
We still need each other#
Men and women need each other. I am not softening the earlier sections by saying that. The earlier sections are why this one has to be said out loud.
If I decide women do not account for harm, and I stop there, I become a man who cannot be loved without a pre-written case against the person in front of me. If women decide men are the hazard, they miss the man who was actually harmed and is trying, slowly and badly, to come back to baseline without becoming cruel. The feed wants both of those endings. They are lucrative. They are also lonely.
Need is not a demand that she soothe me, or that I absorb a harm and call it maturity. Need is a specific person, and it is reciprocal. Heard, held, helped. That is still what I think love is when it is real. I am with someone now who does not need me destabilised in order to feel steady herself. My nervous system can tell the difference. It took a long time to trust the difference. Peace was suspicious at first. It is less suspicious now. I wrote that down when the alarm finally quieted, in my nervous system is no longer on fire.
The boundary is the frame. I will not hand it to a person who needs my confusion in order to stay innocent. I will not hand it to a feed that needs my contempt in order to get paid. I will tell the truth about how long I take to come down, because pretending I am fine by morning is how the harm gets renamed as my personality. And I will not let that truth curdle into a war with half the species.
The person I need is not a demographic. She is particular. So is the man she needs. Anything that trains us to hate the category is training us to miss the person.
The frame stays mine. The rumination is real, and it is not wisdom. Baseline takes as long as it takes. The accountability, in my experience, usually does not arrive, and I have stopped parking my life in the space where it would have stood. My feeling will be ranked second in a lot of rooms. I am leaving those rooms. Men and women, the actual ones, still have to find each other. I intend to.
References#
- Freyd, Violations of power, adaptive blindness, and betrayal trauma theory (1997), including the DARVO description
- Harsey and Freyd, Deny, Attack, and Reverse Victim and Offender (DARVO): influence on perceived perpetrator and victim credibility
- Cooper and Russell, Insistence on sameness, repetitive negative thinking and mental health in autistic and non-autistic adults
- Williams, McKenney and Gotham, Investigating the structure of trait rumination in autistic adults
- Nolen-Hoeksema, Wisco and Lyubomirsky, Rethinking rumination (2008)
- Brosschot, Gerin and Thayer, The perseverative cognition hypothesis
- Physiological concomitants of perseverative cognition: a systematic review and meta-analysis
- Office for National Statistics, Suicides in England and Wales, 2024 registrations
- Samaritans, response to the 2024 England suicide registrations
- Samaritans, gender and suicide
- Brady, Wills, Jost, Tucker and Van Bavel, Emotion shapes the diffusion of moralized content in social networks (2017)
- My senses are 10x, and I have no filter, on this site
- I need the why, on this site
- Feeling more is not emotional intelligence, on this site
- Depression, SSRIs, and low testosterone, on this site
- My nervous system is no longer on fire, on this site
- Samaritans (call 116 123 in the UK and Ireland)