I have two minds, and there is no in-between
Nathan Chadwick · · 11 min read
Listen
TLDRRead the short version
- I do not have a slider between reason and feeling. I have two minds. One is logical. One is highly emotional. There is no in-between.
- The logical mind arrives complete. It can see the fact, name the pattern, and write the sentence while the feeling is still at full volume.
- The emotional mind does not knock. It occupies. There is no setting in here called quite upset.
- Both at once is not a mixture. The logical mind can narrate the flood accurately and still not turn it down. A commentary is not a middle.
- The diagram people are handed draws an overlap and calls it wisdom. I can describe the overlap. I do not find a mind living there.
- When I let the logical mind choose, the other mind does not get smaller. It gets outranked. Outranking is the closest thing I have to a middle, and it is not one.
Two minds#
I have two minds. They are both mine. They are both awake. One is logical. One is highly emotional. There is no in-between.
People hear that and picture a temperament. A man who is mostly a thinker, with feelings somewhere in the mix. Or a man who is very emotional, and the logic is what he uses once he has calmed down. Both pictures have a middle. A bit of one, a bit of the other, a place where they have been stirred into something you could sit next to.
I have looked for that place. It is not in my head.
What I have is two full signals. The logical mind is not a calmed-down emotion. The emotional mind is not logic that got loud. They do not dilute each other. On a quiet day, one of them is simply the one speaking. On a hard day, both of them are speaking, at full scale, in the same second. That second is not balance. It is two occupants. There is no third chair.
The logical one#
The logical mind wants the structure.
It wants the why. It can hold a fact I hate. It can see the pattern in a conversation while the conversation is still happening: who moved the frame, which sentence was a feeling dressed up as a fact, what will still be true at 8am. It writes cleanly. It can be kind without becoming the weather. When it is the one at the keyboard, the paragraph comes out in order, and the order feels like relief.
This is the mind that wrote feeling more is not emotional intelligence. Feelings are data. They are not a verdict. A flooded brain cannot solve. I still believe every line of that. I believed it while I was flooded, which is the whole problem this post is about. The belief and the flood were both at full strength. Neither one edited the other into something milder.
The logical mind is not coldness in a clever coat. Coldness would be the other mind having left. I do not get the leaving. I get a mind that can describe the feeling with the precision of someone standing outside it, while the feeling is happening in the same body. People meet the description and think the feeling went. The feeling did not go. The description is a second mind, not a smaller emotion.
The emotional one#
The emotional mind does not arrive as a tint.
When it is here, it is the size of the event. Shame, anger, love, fear, grief. They do not come in portions. There is the thing, and the thing is total. I can tell you which one it is. I can tell you what set it off. I cannot tell you a percentage. "A bit hurt" is a sentence I understand in other people. I do not have the room it is spoken from.
I have written about volume before. In my senses are 10x, and I have no filter the gain is on the way in from the world. This is the same gain pointed inward. A mood in someone else's face can land in my chest before I have agreed to care about it. My own mood does not ask either. It takes the chair.
Highly emotional, for me, is not crying at a film and calling that depth. It is a nervous system that treats the feeling as the situation. The body agrees before the sentence does. Heart, stomach, the urge to speak, the urge to leave, the urge to fix it now. Arnsten's review of stress and the prefrontal cortex describes what that urgency does to thinking. Even fairly mild uncontrollable stress rapidly impairs prefrontal abilities, working memory included, and the same chemistry strengthens the amygdala. The account in that literature is a switch. The thoughtful cortex loses the wheel. The more reactive system takes it.
I recognise the reactive system. I do not recognise the switch. The logical mind does not leave the building. It stays, it comments, and it cannot take the wheel back just by being correct. The emotional mind is at full volume. The logical mind is also at full volume. That is coexistence. The paper describes a coup.
The logical mind hates "now is enormous" when "now" is a misread. The emotional mind does not experience it as a misread. It experiences it as the room being on fire. Both of those reports are sincere. That is what coexisting means. Two sincere reports. No averaged report.
Both at once is not a middle#
This is the part that gets tidied up by everyone who hears it.
If both minds are present, surely that is the mixture. Surely that is balance. The wise version. The grown-up version. Half and half.
Both at once is not half of anything.
I can be inside the emotional mind and hear the logical mind narrating it, in full sentences, in real time. You are flooded. This feeling is not the fact. Your chest is arguing. The person in front of you said a smaller thing than the thing your body heard. The narration is accurate. I would trust it if I read it the next morning. It does not turn the volume down. It sits next to the volume and describes it, the way a commentator describes a match he is also playing in.
Naming the feeling is supposed to help. Lieberman and colleagues put people in a scanner and had them label emotional faces. Putting the feeling into a word, compared with other ways of looking at the same faces, lined up with less activity in the amygdala and more activity in a right prefrontal region. The task was pictures, not a life. The lesson people still take out of it is the one I was offered: say what you feel, and the feeling will step back.
I say what I feel. I am good at saying what I feel. The feeling does not step back. The sentence and the storm are both complete. If naming built a middle, I would live there, because I name things constantly inside my own head. Naming is the logical mind doing its job. It is not a tunnel between the two.
Marsha Linehan's skills manual draws the picture the culture now repeats. Reasonable mind is cool. In it you are ruled by facts, reason, logic, and what will actually work. Emotion mind is hot. In it you are ruled by mood, feeling, and the urge to do or say the thing now. Wise mind is the overlap: you see the value of both, and you know what to do. The handout is two circles. The overlap is the point of the drawing. She calls it the middle path.
I can teach the drawing. I have tried to stand where the circles cross. What I find, when I am honest, is the two circles at full ink, and a crossing that does not contain a third experience. I can hold the fact and the feeling in the same minute. Holding both is a sequence the logical mind performs. It is not a place where they have become one weather. The minute still has two climates.
Metcalfe and Mischel described a hot system and a cool one, to explain how a person waits instead of grabbing. The hot system is fast and emotional. The cool system knows, and it can decline to be run by the hot one. Their model is a negotiation. The cool system inhibits. Inhibition would be a taper, and a taper would be a kind of middle. What I get, a lot of the time, is the cool system's commentary without the cool system's brake. The logical mind sees the play. The emotional mind has already committed the body. Seeing is not steering.
What I do not mean#
I am one person. I do not have two personalities.
I do not lose time. I do not find a gap where someone else was driving and I was gone. I remember the logical sentence and the emotional surge as the same hour, the same man. There is no second name. There is no handover I wake up from. If the phrase "two minds" sent you looking for a split where the parts do not share a memory, that is a different thing, and it is not this. I have one continuous life. The inner life does not grade.
I also know what I feel. Some of the autism research on emotion finds trouble identifying and describing the feeling, and a lot of it finds the feeling turned up. Samson, Huber and Gross reported both in the same group of adults: more negative emotion than the comparison group, and, for about two-thirds, enough difficulty identifying and describing feelings to cross an alexithymia line. The second finding is not my report. I can identify the feeling. I can describe it while it is happening. The first finding is my report. The emotion is larger, and the description does not shrink it.
Mazefsky and colleagues put that amplification near the centre of the literature: stronger emotional reactions, and a harder time regulating them. They argue that the regulation problem may belong to autism itself, not only to a second illness parked on top. I am not using their paper to label anyone in the room, including me. I am using it against the cartoon. The cartoon says autism deletes feeling and leaves a logic machine. The logic machine is real. The amplification is real. The cartoon kept one and threw the other away. I do not get to throw either away.
There is no quite#
Other people seem to move on a gradient. They notice. They feel it a bit. They think about it a bit. They pick a tone that is neither the raw feeling nor the briefing. The conversation lives in that band. I can see the band. I visit it the way I visit the pause before I speak, the pause I wrote about when I wrote about having no filter. I do not reside there.
A hard conversation goes one of two ways, and sometimes both, and never the mixed drink.
If I speak from the emotional mind, the intensity is honest and the fact is often already bent toward it. Too much, too fast, too total. The other person is answering a fire. I am in a fire. We are not in the same event.
If I speak from the logical mind, the sentence is clean, and it reads as distance. I have said the true thing. I have not said it at the size the emotional mind is living it, because there is no honest sentence at half the size. The emotional mind is still in the chair. It was not consulted down to a moderate. It was asked to wait. Waiting is not a feeling of medium strength. Waiting is one mind holding the wheel.
People who love me sometimes ask for the middle on purpose. Meet me halfway. Don't be so intense, and don't go far away either. I understand the request. I would like to grant it. Halfway is the room I cannot find. I can give you the clear sentence. I can give you the full feeling, named, without handing it the steering wheel. I can give you both, stated as two facts. I cannot average them. Averaged is the in-between. Averaged is the state where I would be a little hurt, a little clear, and easy to sit beside. That state is a report I keep hearing from other people. It is not a report I can make from in here.
This joins the thing I cannot drop. In I need the why, an unexplained fact stays an open file. The emotional mind opens files at full size. The logical mind refuses to close them on a guess. So I get the largest possible feeling and the strictest possible standard for what would settle it, in the same hour. That combination is the two minds doing their jobs at once. There is no clerk between them to round the number down.
Outranking is not a mixture#
I am not taking back the other post.
When a decision has to be made, the logical mind should take it. Reality does not negotiate with a nervous system. A feeling can tell me that something matters. It cannot tell me what is true, or what will still be a good idea once the body has climbed down. I will keep handing that mind the pen. I have been the man who handed the other one the pen, and I have watched it spend a whole night building a case that was mostly temperature.
What I want understood is what that choice is, and what it costs.
It is not integration. Integration would be one mind that had taken the other in. A voice that was already both. An overlap with someone living in it. I do not hear that voice. I hear two, and I give one of them the pen. The one without the pen does not fade out to make the picture neater. It stays at full volume and loses the vote.
Outranking is the closest thing I have to a middle. It is a hierarchy, not a mixture. The emotional mind stays evidence. The logical mind stays the one who decides. Winning the decision does not turn that mind into half a feeling. Losing it does not turn the feeling into half a fact.
If you are in the room with me, you will sometimes meet the one who decides and think the feeling left. It did not leave. You will sometimes meet the feeling and think the clear sentence was an act I dropped. It was not an act. It was the other mind, still present, outvoted for that minute.
There is no in-between. There is only which one I hand the pen, and the fact that the other one is still in the room, wide awake, not even slightly less itself.
References#
- Arnsten, Stress signalling pathways that impair prefrontal cortex structure and function (Nature Reviews Neuroscience, 2009)
- Lieberman, Eisenberger, Crockett, Tom, Pfeifer, and Way, Putting feelings into words: affect labeling disrupts amygdala activity (Psychological Science, 2007)
- Linehan, DBT Skills Training Handouts and Worksheets, states of mind: reasonable mind, emotion mind, wise mind
- Metcalfe and Mischel, A hot/cool-system analysis of delay of gratification (Psychological Review, 1999)
- Samson, Huber, and Gross, Emotion regulation in Asperger's syndrome and high-functioning autism (Emotion, 2012)
- Mazefsky, Herrington, Siegel, Scarpa, Maddox, Scahill, and White, The role of emotion regulation in autism spectrum disorder (JAACAP, 2013)
- Feeling more is not emotional intelligence, on this site
- My senses are 10x, and I have no filter, on this site
- I need the why, on this site
- Samaritans (call 116 123 in the UK and Ireland)