Smile. You look sad.
Nathan Chadwick · · 9 min read
Listen
TLDRRead the short version
- People have told me to smile for as long as I can remember. It arrives as concern. It lands as a correction.
- They said I looked sad when I was not sad. They said I looked grumpy when I was not grumpy. Most of the time my face was just at rest.
- A neutral face is not a status report. Other people fill a quiet face in, often with something negative, and then ask me to fix their reading by performing a smile.
- I am autistic. The face I make on my own is not the one people expect, and the smile they want is a job. Doing it because I was told to is masking.
- If you want to know how I am, ask, and believe the answer. Do not narrate my face back to me as if you were the one inside it.
The line#
Smile.
You look sad.
What's wrong?
Cheer up.
You look grumpy.
I have heard a version of that for as long as I can remember. At school. At home. At work. From people I barely knew, and from people close to me. Someone would look at my face for a second and decide it was a problem they were allowed to mention.
Nothing was wrong. I was not sad. I was not grumpy. I was standing there, or sitting there, thinking about whatever I was thinking about, with my face doing what it does when I am not putting on a show.
They did not take that as an answer. The face had already given evidence. My sentence was the thing that needed correcting.
I know this line gets aimed at women by strangers who think a face is public property. That happens, and it is its own harm. It is not the version I lived. Mine came from people who thought they were reading me. The tone was concern, or irritation. The shape was the same. My face had been taken as evidence, and I was being asked to change the evidence.
Rest is not a mood#
People treat a face like a live readout. A mouth that is not smiling means sad. A brow that is not moving means angry. No smile means something is wrong, and the something is yours to explain, out loud, for them.
A face at rest is a face at rest. It is bone, muscle, and habit. It is what is left when you are not acting. Some people rest with the corners of the mouth slightly up, so the default gets filed under friendly. I do not. The resting position is quieter. Flatter. Easy to file under sad, or under grumpy, depending on who is looking and what they walked in expecting.
I know the difference from the inside. Sad has a weight. Grumpy has a heat. Neutral has neither. Neutral is the face I have when I am thinking, listening, tired, comfortable, or simply not performing. Those are not the same state. From the outside they get collapsed into one comment.
The comment is almost never "your face is hard for me to read". It is "you are sad", or "you are in a mood". They skip the reading and go straight to the verdict. Then they want the face changed, so the verdict can be withdrawn.
You look sad#
This is the one that used to make me doubt myself.
Someone looks at me and decides I am unhappy. They say it kindly, which makes it harder to refuse. If I say I am not, I sound like I am hiding it. If I explain, I am now discussing a feeling I do not have. If I smile to end it, I have agreed that the smile was the missing piece, and that my actual answer was not enough.
Concern and correction wear the same sentence. "You look sad" can mean "I care how you are". It can also mean "your face is making me uncomfortable, please adjust it". I have had both. They are not labelled. I only find out which one it was by what happens after I say I am fine.
A person who wanted to know asks, hears the answer, and updates. A person who wanted a display hears "I'm fine" and says it again. Smile. You still look sad. It cannot be that bad.
It was not bad. That was the point. There was no "it".
After enough years of this, you start checking. You catch a reflection and wonder what they are about to say. You walk into a room already holding a face that will not trigger the comment. That is not confidence. That is surveillance you learned to do to yourself, because other people would not stop doing it.
I have written about what chronic misreading does. In the post on bullying and social anxiety I said being seen felt dangerous, because being seen usually meant being seen wrong. A comment on the face is a small version of that. You were visible for a second, and the story they told about that second was not yours.
You look grumpy#
The other version drops the kindness.
Sad at least pretends to be worry. Grumpy is a charge. It says your face is a mood you are inflicting on the room. It says you owe people a softer expression before you have said a word.
I have been called grumpy while I was content. Concentrating. Listening. Waiting. Happy, even, in the quiet way that does not rearrange my mouth. The contentment did not count, because it did not look like their picture of contentment.
This is the same mistake I wrote about in feeling more is not emotional intelligence. People score the display. They do not score the state. A face that is not performing gets marked down as closed, cold, or angry, and the person behind it is told to do better. The better they want is a smile that settles them.
Arlie Hochschild called the effort to change a feeling, in yourself or in the room, emotion work. "Smile" is that work, handed over in one word. Change your face so I feel all right. Your actual mood is beside the point. The job is the audience.
I am not against warmth. I smile when something is funny. I smile at people I love, because I want to. What I am pushing back on is the idea that a resting face is a fault, and that someone else's comfort is a tax my mouth has to pay for being in the room.
The smile they order#
There is a smile that only exists because someone asked for it.
It arrives late. You can feel it being put on. The mouth moves because it was told to move. Sometimes the eyes join in, because you have had years of practice, and sometimes they do not. The person who demanded it can often tell. They wanted proof that you are fine in the way they recognise. A built smile does not give them that. A true answer did not either. The exchange has no winning move. It only has an ending.
I got good at ending it. That is not the same as being at ease with it.
The cost is that your own face starts to feel like a risk. You watch it in meetings, in photos, in the second before you say hello. You hold a shape that is slightly more acceptable than the one you walked in with. Hold it long enough and the face gets tired, which sounds absurd until you have done it for a day. Then the shape slips, someone says you look sad, and the loop starts again.
I would rather be read accurately than be read as cheerful. Accurate includes neutral. Neutral is allowed to look like nothing much is happening, because nothing much is.
The autistic face#
I am autistic. Across a whole life, this lines up.
The small ongoing social face, the one other people treat as the default, is not free for me. The mobile eyebrows. The mouth that comments on the conversation while someone else is talking. The smile that stays up so the room knows you are safe. I notice I am not doing it. I can do it on purpose. On purpose is work.
The National Autistic Society describes masking as hiding autistic traits in order to be accepted. One of the examples is using facial expressions that would not come naturally, including by copying someone else's. That is the smile on command. It is not a mood. It is a strategy, built because the unperformed face kept being answered with a comment, a worry, or a story about my character.
The research splits in the same place I feel the split. A meta-analysis of facial expression in autism found that autistic people produce expressions less often and for less time, and that other people judge those expressions as lower in quality. The difference is larger when nobody has asked for an expression than when an expression is prompted. Intensity is not the gap. The spontaneous face is. Asked for a face, the gap shrinks. Left alone, the face I actually live in is the one that collects the comment.
The other half of this is not about my muscles.
Sasson and colleagues found that people form a less favourable impression of autistic adults within seconds, from video or from a still image, and report less interest in talking to them or spending time with them. When the same raters only had the words, with the face and the voice removed, the harsher rating disappeared. What was said was not the problem. The manner was. A lifetime of "you look sad" and "you look grumpy" is that finding, said by people who thought they were being observant.
Damian Milton called the wider pattern the double empathy problem. The miss runs both ways. Autistic people read the room differently. Non-autistic people misread autistic people, and then treat their misreading as the fact of us. "You look sad" is a misreading delivered with a confident voice.
It is also a general habit of face perception, not a special rule that only applies to me. Neutral faces are not read as blank. In one study, neutral faces that structurally resembled anger were judged as more threatening, and neutral faces that resembled disgust or fear picked up a more negative rating. An emotion detector fires on a resemblance. The result gets stored as a trait. Grumpy is one name for that trait. Unfriendly is another. Sad is the softer label from the same habit: a quiet face must mean something, so a meaning gets assigned, and the person wearing the face is asked to agree with it.
You do not have to be autistic to live with that assignment. I am saying that for me the autism is part of why the social face does not run on its own, and why the comments never taught me anything about my mood. They taught me that a mood was going to be issued.
I know when I am sad. I have been sad. It does not feel like a still face and a clear head while someone else files the report. It feels like sadness. I also know when I am irritated. I can say so. The times I am writing about are the times neither of those was true, and the comment arrived anyway.
What I am asking#
Ask me how I am, if you want to know.
Then believe the answer.
If I say I am fine, I am fine. If I say I am tired, I am tired. If I am annoyed, I will say I am annoyed. I am not being cryptic. I have written before about needing the why. I will give you the why of a mood in one sentence, when you have asked about the mood.
Do not tell me what my face means. You are looking at it. You are not in it. Only one of those positions has the information.
"I can't tell how you are" is honest. I will answer that. "You look sad" is a guess stated as a fact. "Smile" is an instruction. I will take the honest sentence. I will not keep rearranging my mouth so a guess can feel as if it came true.
A smile I choose is real. A smile you order is a costume. The resting face is not the rude version of me. It is the one that was already there.
References#
- National Autistic Society, Masking
- Trevisan, Hoskyn and Birmingham, Facial expression production in autism: a meta-analysis (2018)
- Sasson, Faso, Nugent, Lovell, Kennedy and Grossman, Thin-slice judgments of autism (Scientific Reports, 2017)
- Milton, On the ontological status of autism: the double empathy problem (2012)
- Said, Sebe and Todorov, Structural resemblance to emotional expressions predicts evaluation of emotionally neutral faces (2009)
- Hochschild's emotion work, discussed in Emotion regulation and emotion work (Frontiers, 2012)
- Feeling more is not emotional intelligence, on this site
- Bullying, social anxiety, and how RuneScape was my escape, on this site
- I need the why, on this site