Get to him before the crisis
Nathan Chadwick · · 12 min read
Listen
TLDRRead the short version
- The deaths are early and the help is late. Waiting for a man to announce a crisis is how you meet him at the worst version of the problem.
- In England, 15.4% of men have a common mental health condition, against 24.2% of women. Men are about a third of NHS Talking Therapies referrals, and about three quarters of suicides in England.
- Before it looks like a crisis it looks like a short fuse, more drink, more work, going quiet, or 'I'm fine'. People walk past that and call it his personality.
- A lot of men have one person they might tell. If she invalidates it, will not hear it, or turns it back on him, he does not find a second audience. He closes.
- A poster in November is not care. Care is noticing the sign while it is still a bad month, and not putting him on trial for saying it.
- If this is you, Samaritans is 116 123. You do not have to win the argument before you call.
The queue#
The help is a queue. You join it by saying, out loud, that you need it.
A lot of men do not join until the thing has already been living in the body for months. Sometimes they do not join until it is trying to kill them. The people around them call that his choice. It is also the design. A service that waits to be asked will meet men at the crisis, because the crisis is the first point at which a lot of them are allowed to count.
I am tired of the posters. Men's mental health matters. It is okay not to be okay. Check on your mates. November fills up with it. Then a man is short with you on a Tuesday, or drinking on a night he does not usually drink, or flat in a way you could see if you felt like seeing it, and the room files it under his personality. The talk was for the timeline. The man was an inconvenience.
More has to be done, and it has to be done earlier than a slogan. Proactive means someone goes and gets him while he can still be got. Waiting is not neutral. Waiting is a decision to meet the worst version of the problem and call the timing his fault.
The numbers do not match the talk#
Both sets of numbers are real. They describe different doors.
In England, the Adult Psychiatric Morbidity Survey for 2023/24 found a common mental health condition in one in five adults. The split was 24.2% of women and 15.4% of men. Anxiety and depression, as that interview counts them, sit more often with women. I am not interested in pretending the survey is a conspiracy. Those symptoms are common, they hurt, and women carry more of them.
The deaths go the other way. In England and Wales in 2024 the suicide rate was 17.6 per 100,000 men and 5.7 per 100,000 women. Samaritans, on the England registrations, said three in four of those deaths were men. If that is you, the number in the UK and Ireland is 116 123. It does not require a polished explanation of your life.
The services sit closer to the survey than to the deaths. The British Association for Behavioural and Cognitive Psychotherapies, citing the NHS Talking Therapies annual report for 2023-24, put men at 32.6% of referrals (597,540) and women at 65.8% (1,203,832). The same note says that when men do get in, the outcomes are comparable. The treatment is not the mystery. The arrival is. And the arrival is late. The BABCP's reading is that a waiting list lands harder on men and boys, because they often delay until they are already in crisis. Their president, Stirling Moorey, said the data shows men are less likely to seek support even when they need it most.
That is the whole shape. Women are more often in the counted distress. Men are more often the ones who die. A strategy that opens when someone presents the counted version, in a full sentence, in office hours, will keep missing the second group until a coroner is involved. I have lived the smaller version of not being looked at. Twenty years of depression, assessed and prescribed for, and nobody took the blood. I wrote that in the piece on SSRIs and testosterone. Same habit. Everyone had already decided what sort of problem I was, so nobody went looking for a different one.
What it looks like before it is a crisis#
The early version rarely looks like the poster.
It looks like a shorter fuse. More drink. Later nights at work. Training that has stopped being training and become a place to disappear. Cancelled plans. A flatness his friends describe, afterwards, as "he seemed fine, a bit quiet". The sentence "I'm fine", delivered in the voice of a man who would rather take the bin out than have this conversation.
Time to Change, in the survey behind Ask Twice, asked 3,000 men in Britain and found the translation layer. 31% were more likely to say they were stressed. 30% that they were not feeling themselves. Only a quarter would tell a male friend outright that they were struggling. 35% said that if they wanted to talk, they would ask how their friend was, and hope the friend asked them back. The hint is doing a lot of work, and it is easy to miss if you prefer the first answer.
The clinical version of this miss is old. Wolfgang Rutz's reading of the Gotland GP training was that teaching doctors the standard picture of depression cut female suicides and left male suicides almost untouched. What he then described was a male pattern the training had not taught them to see: low stress tolerance, acting out, poor impulse control, drink, a family history of depression and suicide. I will not pretend a small programme on a Swedish island in the 1980s is a modern trial. The useful part is the miss. Later, in men being treated for alcohol problems, a standard depression scale found it in 17%. The Gotland scale, built for that male pattern, found a probable or definite depression in 39%.
So the sign people walk past is often the sign. Irritability is easier to resent than to read. Withdrawal is easier to take personally. Drink is easier to file under lifestyle. Overwork is easier to praise. "He's being a lot" is easier than "he has been like this for six weeks and nobody has asked twice". The poster says look for distress. The room looks for a likeable patient. A man who is snappy, drinking, and insisting he is fine does not audition well. People decide they do not care, and they call the decision realism.
The person he tells#
When he does speak, it is often to one person.
Samaritans, on men in mid-life, found that past 30 the supportive friendships thin, and a female partner becomes the main emotional support. The report's hope is that she is the one who helps him recognise the distress and get help. Sometimes that is true. The structure is still a single point of failure. A relationship breakdown raises suicide risk more for men, which is what you would expect if she was the only person who knew, and then she is gone, or she is the stress.
I have lived the version where she is not the help. You tell her you are not alright. Three things happen, sometimes all in the same evening.
She invalidates it. You are overreacting. You are too much. Other people cope. The feeling is not taken as information about your life. It is taken as a flaw in you, and the conversation becomes the flaw.
Or she does not want to hear it. The subject moves. The sigh gets there before you finish the sentence. Your low mood is an inconvenience in the house. She wanted the evening she had planned, and your distress is the thing that ruined it. You can feel the request to put it back in the box.
Or she turns it back on you. Your sadness lands as an accusation, so now you are comforting her for the pain you tried to hand over. Or the distress itself is taken as evidence that you are unsafe, controlling, dramatic, not over it, too much work. The original sentence is gone. You are on trial for having said it.
That third move is the frame, and I have written it properly in I will never let someone control my frame again. It is not only a trick for arguments about what she did. It is what happens to a man who was only trying to say that he was struggling. My feeling comes second. Her discomfort at hearing it becomes the event. I have also done the other job, regulating myself and then the room, and been told the regulation was coldness. That double load is in feeling more is not emotional intelligence. The point here is narrower. The one place he was told it was safe to open is the place that punished the opening.
He does not become more honest after that. He becomes exact about who never hears it again.
The survey found the bruise. 39% of those men had already had a disappointing reaction when they shared something about their mental health. 42% kept it in because they did not want to be a burden. Then the culture blames him for not talking, as if the last time had gone well.
Men shut the door too. The mate who says man up. In that survey, 42% called "man up" and "grow up" conversation blockers. Banter is a hobby until it is the reason the real sentence never arrives. I am not building a religion in which women fail and men are acquitted. I am saying the person standing in front of him decides whether the poster was a lie. The sex of that person is not the mechanism. The mechanism is that his distress is optional to everyone except him, right up until it becomes everyone else's emergency.
The couple research does not say she will fail you. It says expression follows the response he expects. Ruan, Reis and Clark found that people say the feeling, including anxiety they would otherwise hold, when they believe a close partner will actually receive it. They also note the risk on the other side of that bet: a partner can be inattentive, belittling, or rejecting. People open up when they expect the first. They stop when they have learned to expect the second. That is not a closed man. That is a man who already ran the experiment.
I am with someone now who does not do this to me. The difference is not subtle, and it took a long time to trust it. I wrote that down when the alarm finally quieted, in my nervous system is no longer on fire. Knowing a good room exists does not make the bad rooms fictional. It makes them a choice I no longer have to sit in.
November#
Virtue signalling is a costume that photographs well and fails at the first inconvenient symptom.
Movember. International Men's Day. The gym poster. The tile that says check on your mates, posted by someone who has not checked on a specific mate since June. I have already said the slogan dies in the room where his pain indicts her. This is the earlier test. He is not in crisis. He is just worse than he was, in ways a person who liked him could name.
Ask Twice was the campaign that understood the script. The first "I'm fine" is the costume he thinks you want. The second question is the actual offer. If the answer, once it comes, gets annoyance, a joke, a lecture, silence, or a flip in which you are now the wounded party, the post was the performance. You cared about men's mental health as a topic. You did not care about the man who was showing you the signs.
People are very willing to be sad about a man after the fact. They are much less willing to be inconvenienced by him before it. The funeral speech is cheap. The Tuesday conversation costs the evening, and it costs the flattering story in which he is difficult rather than in trouble. A lot of rooms pick the story.
Go and get him#
Proactive is not a better graphic. It is a behaviour, done while he still looks like a man having a bad month.
A mate asks twice, and then lets the answer stand. No fix, no banter, no ranking of whose week was worse. If he talks about stress, or not feeling himself, that is the sentence. You do not get to wait for the word depression.
A partner can hear "I am not alright" without holding a trial, including when some of the pain is about her. She can be hurt. She can want a repair later. She does not get to cross-examine the disclosure and still call herself a safe place to be ill. The first minute is receipt. Invalidating it, refusing to hear it, or turning it back on him is how you teach him that the safe place was a slogan.
A GP looks again, instead of closing a story he decided in ten minutes. Medication can be the right tool. It is a bad substitute for the question nobody asked.
A service stops treating a late arrival as proof he is the wrong kind of patient. The outcomes, once men are in the room, are not the scandal. The door is. A waiting list is hard on everybody. It is brutal for someone who already waited until the wheels were coming off, and who will not wait again. Moorey asked for the mental health strategy to include a real plan for getting men into talking therapies, including men who need more than the standard route, and for the help to be there when they reach for it. Symptom recognition was on that list. A poster does not do it.
And nobody leaves the whole job on one partner. One confidant is one failure away from silence. Mates who can hear a serious thing. A clinician who will look. A helpline that does not need the relationship to be the audience. Samaritans have been saying for years that the point is to reach men before the build-up becomes the crisis. That sentence is the policy. It is not most people's actual behaviour.
I will not keep handing the only copy of how I am to a room that ranks it second. The men who are still in those rooms need someone else to move first. Not in November. This week. Before it is a crisis, and before the people who would not listen get to be shocked.
If it is you: Samaritans, 116 123, free, at any hour, in the UK and Ireland. CALM, 0800 58 58 58, from 5pm to midnight. In England, NHS 111, and ask for mental health. You do not need the right wording. You do not need to have won at home.
References#
- NHS England Digital, Adult Psychiatric Morbidity Survey 2023/24, common mental health conditions
- Office for National Statistics, Suicides in England and Wales, 2024 registrations
- Samaritans, response to the 2024 England suicide registrations
- Samaritans, gender and suicide
- Samaritans, Men and suicide: why it's a social issue
- Samaritans, suicide risk factors for middle-aged men
- BABCP, men and access to NHS Talking Therapies
- NHS England Digital, NHS Talking Therapies annual report, 2023-24
- Rutz, Male depression and suicide
- Zierau and colleagues, The Gotland Male Depression Scale in men treated for alcohol problems
- Ruan, Reis and Clark, Perceived partner responsiveness encourages emotional expression
- Time to Change, Ask Twice, as reported from their survey of 3,000 men
- Depression, SSRIs, and low testosterone, on this site
- I will never let someone control my frame again, on this site
- Feeling more is not emotional intelligence, on this site
- My nervous system is no longer on fire, on this site
- Samaritans (call 116 123 in the UK and Ireland)
- CALM (call 0800 58 58 58, 5pm to midnight)