Crazy-making: I was certain I had BPD
Nathan Chadwick · · 10 min read
Listen
TLDRRead the short version
- I was certain I had BPD. I had never been like that before, and I was thriving in every other part of my life. The symptoms lived in one relationship.
- I am neurodivergent. I am autistic. Emotional dysregulation is already how that nervous system works, and a crazy-making relationship doubles it. The size of the feeling is the sum, not a personality.
- Crazy-making is the climate: instability, passive aggression, and insults dressed up as jokes, honesty, or concern, so that noticing them makes you the problem.
- A nervous system can only be poked for so long. The snap is an alarm, the thing people call an amygdala hijack, not a personality you brought into the room.
- When the reaction is then held up as the whole story, that is reactive abuse. The checklist looks like BPD because it was filled in during the fire.
- What I had was situational. It was PTSD. BPD is real, and it has to show up across a life, not inside one doorway. This is an account, not a diagnosis.
I was certain#
I was certain I had borderline personality disorder.
The symptoms were not subtle. Mood that could turn on a sentence. A fear of being dropped that sat in my chest like a fact. Anger I did not recognise as mine. A version of me I would have sworn, a year earlier, did not exist. I went looking for a name, and BPD fitted the worst months so cleanly that I stopped looking for a cause.
The cause was the relationship.
I had never been like that in the past. I was thriving in every other part of my life. Work held. Friends held. The ordinary week held. The only place I became someone I did not know was next to one person. When I was away from them, the symptoms did not follow me out of the house. A personality comes with you when you leave the room. This did not.
I am not a clinician. This is an account of my own life, not a diagnosis, and not a verdict on anyone who does have BPD. The disorder is real. People who have it are not a punchline, and they are not "the crazy ex". What I had was situational. It was PTSD. The certainty was the trap crazy-making is built to produce.
What crazy-making actually is#
Crazy-making is the climate, not the snap.
It is what a relationship feels like when the ground keeps moving and you are then punished for stumbling. Instability is enough on its own. Warm, then cold, then warm, with no map and no repair. Your body learns that closeness is a coin toss, so you start managing their mood in order to stay near a person you love. You call that effort. Your nervous system calls it threat.
Passive aggression does the next part of the work without ever standing still long enough to be quoted. A silence that is a punishment. A compliment with a blade in it. A plan that gets ruined and then denied. You cannot hold it up and say "there". You can only feel the room change.
Then the insults. Some of them arrive dressed as a joke, as honesty, as concern, so that naming them makes you look mad. Some of them do not bother with a costume. They are delivered as if describing you is the same as describing the weather, and if you flinch you have proved you cannot handle the truth. Either way the second move is identical. You noticed. Noticing becomes the offence. Your perception becomes the symptom they point at.
Stay in that long enough and you will diagnose yourself with whatever disorder explains a person who cannot trust their own eyes. That is the point of the climate. You leave the argument holding a label, and they leave it holding the reasonable voice.
I was already dysregulated#
I am neurodivergent. I am autistic. That is half of this story, not a footnote.
Emotional dysregulation is part of how this nervous system works. Feelings come in hot. Naming them is slow. Coming back down is slower. A change in the room, a tone, a plan that moves, and the body is already spending everything it has to stay level. On an ordinary day I can live with that. I have lived with it at work, with friends, and with former partners. The dysregulation was there. It did not run the house.
The National Autistic Society describes a meltdown as an intense response to an overwhelming situation: a temporary loss of control, not a tantrum and not bad character. Their writing on anxiety in autistic people names the other half, difficulty identifying, understanding, and managing emotions. When the body signal is missed, anger becomes rage before you have a name for it, and the people watching call that immaturity. I wrote about the sensory version of that snap in my senses are 10x, and I have no filter. Irritability that looks like a personality, because the room only saw the last straw.
Crazy-making stacks a second dysregulation on top of the first. Instability, passive aggression, and insults you get punished for noticing are overwhelm that does not stop. A nervous system can only take so much of that. Mine was already spending its budget on being autistic, so the same poking produced a bigger fire, and a longer one. That is the double. Emotional dysregulation was already mine. The relationship found it and turned the dial until I looked like someone with borderline personality disorder.
The size of the feeling is the sum. It is the autistic nervous system, plus one house that would not let the alarm switch off. Added together they tick the boxes. Separated, they are not BPD.
A personality has to show up in every room#
BPD is a real condition. In the UK it is also often called emotionally unstable personality disorder. The NHS groups the difficulties into four broad areas: emotional instability, disturbed patterns of thinking, impulsive behaviour, and intense but unstable relationships. The mood swings, the fear of abandonment, the anger, the sense that you do not know who you are. I could have ticked boxes. Anyone standing inside that relationship could have watched me tick them.
The word that matters is pervasive. Official descriptions call it a pervasive pattern of instability in relationships, self-image, and emotional regulation, beginning by early adulthood and present across a person's contexts, not inside one doorway. NHS England's adult psychiatric survey uses that language. A pattern that is your personality shows up at work, with friends, with former partners, on an ordinary Tuesday when nobody is baiting you.
Mine did not. I had former partners. I had not been that person with them. I was functioning, and more than functioning, everywhere except there. The checklist was a photograph of one room.
If the pattern is in every room of your life, and it was there before any one relationship, that is a different conversation. It belongs with a GP, and then with someone whose job is assessment. The NHS page on diagnosis is the right door for that, not an essay. What I am refusing is the shortcut that takes a nervous system on fire next to one person and files the fire as a character.
Poke anything long enough#
If you poke a dog constantly, it can only take so much.
The snap, when it comes, is information about the poking. You do not invent a personality disorder for the dog and ignore the hand. You stop. A human nervous system is not granted an exemption from that limit. We can live around instability, contempt, and bait for a while, because we can explain it, love the person doing it, and hope the warm version is the real one. Then the alarm stops asking permission.
Harvard's account of the stress response is the plain version of what that alarm is. The amygdala helps process emotion. When it reads danger, it signals the hypothalamus, and adrenaline is in the blood before the thinking part of the brain has finished working out what it is looking at. The wiring is fast enough that the cascade can start before you have consciously decided anything. People call the moment the alarm outruns judgement an amygdala hijack. The phrase is a shorthand, popularised by Daniel Goleman, not a brain scan and not a diagnosis. What it names is familiar if you have been there. You are gone before you have chosen to go. Heart, voice, the message you would never have sent on any other day.
The same piece says the body can overreact to stressors that are not a single life-threatening moment, including difficulties at home, and that repeated activation takes a toll. Chronic stress holds the gas pedal down. A relationship that is unstable as a climate is not a one-off startle. The hijack stops being an incident. It becomes how you are in that one house, and nowhere else.
The reaction becomes the diagnosis#
When you finally fire back, the firing is all that gets kept.
The months of pokes do not make the story. The bark does. Provoke in private, with the coldness and the insults and the ground that will not stay still, then hold the reaction up as proof that you were the disordered one all along. That move has a name: reactive abuse. I have written about the shape of it before, in the post on being put down until the nervous system snaps and in the one about being left to walk home.
The cruel efficiency is that the reaction really does resemble the list. Fear of being left, because being left was the weather. Mood that swung, because the other person was the weather. Anger, because you were provoked past the point any animal stops absorbing it. A self you could not find, because you were being rewritten every time you tried to name what was happening. Those are BPD-like symptoms. They are what an alarm looks like when someone writes it onto a form during the fire. They are a state. They are not a personality you carried in from the rest of your life.
Add autism to that photograph and the boxes get easier to tick. Emotional dysregulation was already mine. The relationship doubled it. Someone scoring only the doubled version gets a personality disorder. They missed the wiring, and they missed the poking.
This is also why "all my exes were crazy" is a warning rather than a sad story. A lot of those people had hit a limit. The person telling the story kept the bark and deleted the poking.
It was PTSD#
What it was, for me, was PTSD.
The NHS describes PTSD as what follows very stressful, frightening, or distressing events, and abuse is one of the causes it names. The symptoms that mapped onto me were on that page: more irritable and more angry than I had ever been, anxious, scanning for danger, the body braced, the relationship still happening in my head after the moment had passed. I had not been that man before. I was not that man in the rest of my life.
When the threat is not one event but an ongoing one that is hard to step out of, the NHS describes complex PTSD on top of the same core: real difficulty controlling your feelings, shame or a persistent negative view of yourself, and persistent problems in relationships. Ongoing domestic abuse is one of the causes it names. NICE says the same thing in its PTSD guideline. Complex PTSD can follow prolonged or repeated threat, including prolonged domestic violence, and it brings severe problems regulating emotion, a view of yourself as diminished, and difficulty staying close to people.
That overlap is why a form filled in during the worst of a crazy-making relationship looks like a personality disorder. The boxes are similar because a terrified nervous system and a pervasive pattern can photograph alike. They are not the same picture. A review in the British Journal of Psychiatry puts the practical difference in clinical terms: the emotional storms in complex PTSD are often specific to the stress, feel alien to the person you otherwise are, and vary as the threat varies. In BPD they are more persistent, and more of a piece with how the person is across life. Trauma has to be there before complex PTSD is even on the table. It does not have to be there for BPD. A plain-language NIHR summary of the research makes the same separation, and notes that the two can also show up together, which is another reason a checklist is not a verdict.
I was the first picture. The storms were alien in size. They were specific to that relationship. They were not how I had been with anyone else, and they were not how I was everywhere else. I was thriving in the rest of my life with the same neurodivergent nervous system. The rest of my life was the control group. The variable was the room.
If you only become unrecognisable under one person's hands, believe the map. The room is the variable. Love does not require you to live braced, and a nervous system that only catches fire around one person is giving you data about that person. I can look at who I was in that house and feel sorry for him without adopting him as my character. He was past his limit. The limit was not the flaw. The limit was the evidence.
If any of this is live for you rather than historical, you do not have to settle the label before you get safe. A GP can start that conversation. If you are in danger, the lines below are the faster door.
References#
Background reading, and support if any of this is happening now.
- NHS, Symptoms of borderline personality disorder
- NHS, Diagnosis of borderline personality disorder
- NHS England, Adult psychiatric morbidity survey: personality disorder
- NHS, PTSD and complex PTSD
- NICE, Post-traumatic stress disorder (NG116)
- British Journal of Psychiatry, Distinguishing complex PTSD and borderline personality disorder
- NIHR ARC North Thames, Complex PTSD and borderline personality disorder
- National Autistic Society, Meltdowns
- National Autistic Society, Anxiety
- National Autistic Society, Interoception and mental wellbeing
- Harvard Health, Understanding the stress response
- DomesticShelters.org, Isn't reactive abuse just victim-blaming?
- Mind, Abuse (UK)
- Samaritans (call 116 123 in the UK and Ireland)
- Refuge, National Domestic Abuse Helpline (0808 2000 247)